Saturday, 10 October 2009

Pixie and Dixie — Scaredycat Dog

Produced and Directed by Bill Hanna and Joe Barbera.
Credits: Animation – Lew Marshall; Layout – Dick Bickenbach; Backgrounds – Fernando Montealegre; Dialogue and Story Sketches – Charlie Shows and Dan Gordon; Titles – Art Goble; Production Supervision – Howard Hanson.
Cast: Pixie, Lion Hound – Don Messick; Dixie, Jinks, Lion Hound’s Twin Brother – Daws Butler.
Production E-12, Huckleberry Hound Show K-006.
First aired: week of Monday, November 3, 1958.
Plot: Pixie and Dixie buy an African Lion Hound to protect them from Jinks, but the dog is afraid of cats.

Pixie and Dixie should have been no-brainer series for Hanna-Barbera to put together. After all, who was more familiar with the ‘cat-chases-mouse, mouse-defeats-cat’ format than Joe and Bill? But what works on the big screen doesn’t necessarily work on the little one at home.

Part of the problem Hanna-Barbera faced with Pixie and Dixie is violence gags don’t always work too well in limited animation, at least in the kind of limited animation where extremes aren’t very extreme. So that leaves it up to the writer to come up with a compelling plot laden with funny dialogue.

It was easier doing that with Huckleberry Hound than with Jinksie and the Meece. In Huck’s case, his comments after getting the snork kicked out of him are incongruous and that’s why they’re funny (as usual, Daws Butler’s expert delivery helps a lot). But Pixie, Dixie and Jinks didn’t have that luxury. The dialogue had to be strong. And, this is one of those unfortunate cartoons where the plot is good, but the rest of Charlie Shows’ story needed a lot of punching up.

The cartoon opens with Pixie and Dixie breaking open a piggy bank (the glint in Dixie’s eyes is a nice extra touch) to reveal $5 in coins. That’s just enough for a trip to the Pet Shoppe (with Dixie reading the “pe” on the store sign). And Shows pads for time by having the Meece check to see if the cat is asleep before going to the store, and again by having Pixie read a sign in the window that anyone can see.


The mice purchase a vicious-looking African Lion Hound to protect them from the menacing cat. And in the process, we get a variation (and not nearly as funny) on the opening scene in Tex Avery’s Wags to Riches (1949) where Spike acts out each character trait he supposedly has as it’s being listed. As Dixie reads off the dog’s attributes—“fierce,” “brave,” “a real fighter” “and in excellent condition”—the dog demonstrates. Shows did the same thing with Yogi and his fish nemesis in The Stout Trout. Perhaps one of the attributes should have been “ready” because the dog shares some design traits with a homophonic Hanna-Barbera dog.



I really like Monte’s stone wall in this cartoon. The colours are light enough so the background doesn’t distract from the action but it’s still a decorative backdrop.

Dixie then strolls to the sleeping Jinks to give him five minutes to get out of town. This bit, and several others in the cartoon, features snap poses, where a character goes from one pose to the next with no in-betweens. Several of the earliest cartoons have that jerky quality. What you see below are two consecutive frames of “action.”


“Tag! You’re it!” says Dixie and runs off, with Jinks in pursuit. Below two sets of consecutive frames. You can see how Lew Marshall (without his characteristic head bobs, I might add) zips them off screen, leaving eyes aplenty.



Ah, but when the cat and dog meet, they’re both afraid and zip off camera. The mice find the dog hiding in an old barrel. There’s a bit of a glitch here as the mice are standing in front of a wooden fence in the medium shot, but in front of a stone fence in the close-up.


Messick uses one of his mush-mouth wimpy voices for the dog, who explains he’s afraid , and then tells the mice to look at the small print on their contract. Sure enough, it reveals the dog is afraid of cats. Since in an H-B cartoon, it’s a rule that characters read newspapers, signs and so on in clear view of the audience, Jinks hears what’s in the contract and decides to take advantage of it. Note below in the front view how Jinks’ eyes are drawn, thinner and farther apart than usual and slanted. There are several scenes where he appears this way.

Here’s where you wish someone like Foster or Maltese was guiding the dialogue because Shows’ lines come off as trite and obvious. “Sic ‘em, boy!” says Dixie. “I’m too sick to sic ‘em,” moans the dog. “You’re a lion hound,” exhorts Pixie. “I’m not really a lion hound,” wails the pooch, “I’m more a chicken-type hound.” Sorry, Charlie, that stuff isn’t exactly crackling with punny wit.


The next scene follows with Charlie padding the cartoon with more irrelevant dialogue. The dog and mice are up a tree. We can hear the sound of wood being chopped. We can see the tree shake. Pixie exclaims, to no one’s utter surprise, “He’s chopping down the tree. Shee!” The line seems to exist only so Shows can get in yet another of his rhyming two-somes he loved to insert in cartoons, as if that concept itself was enough to be a joke.

Jinks now punches the dog in the face in some cycle animation. Again, there are no real outrageous extremes here, so the gag is simply a dog getting punched. We get a nice Chuck Jones’ grinch-like pose next, though, as Jinks gives the mice five minutes to get out of town.


Pixie and Dixie pack their bags and are on their way to homelessness when they’re interrupted by the dog’s twin brother, using Daws’ ‘Jackie Gleason’ voice. You just know if Maltese or Foster were writing here, they’d come up with some oddball response to “Is he scared of cats?” But all Shows can think of is “He can lick his weight in wildcats.”

Dixie goes in the house, bops Jinks on the nose (which vibrates) and lures him outside by running away. The cat passes a dog, not realising it’s the twin brother. Another rhyming two-some comes from Shows: “Didn’t I tell you to get out of town, clown?” Jinks challenges him to a fight but the Gleason-dog’s fist goes pow-right-in-the-kisser before Jinks can throw the old one-two.

We get a different kind of camera effect for some reason here. Footage of vibrating Jinks gives way to a take of a stunned Jinks which is superimposed for a second or so. And, to be sure to save animation, it happens twice.

Dixie explains who is who to the confused cat, who decides to “scat out of town.” He’s chased by the twin brother as the iris comes in to focus on Jinks’ head. His less-than-hilarious topper last line is “You know sumpin’ else? I forgot to pack.” And with that Shows has churned out another story and it’s on to the next cartoon.

Hanna and Barbera are somewhat borrowing from themselves here. The concept of an afraid twin-mistaken identity comes from the Tom and Jerry cartoon Timid Tabby (1956), where Jerry picks on Tom’s frightened visiting cousin. Tex Avery used the mistaken-identity-duplicate-dog idea earlier in Droopy’s Double Trouble and lifting from it might have helped. While it wasn’t one of Tex’s best, that cartoon moves along and some of his explosion gags could have worked in limited animation. But in this cartoon, the even tempo and less-than-hard-hitting humour leave you wanting a lot more.

The music in this one is a familiar mix, with Geordie Hormel’s final piece being faded out instead of bringing the cartoon to a definite end. The fade-out wasn’t unusual in the earliest H-B cartoons.


0:00 - Pixie and Dixie Main Title Theme (Hanna-Barbera-Curtin-Shows).
0:26 - TC 202 ECCENTRIC COMEDY (Bill Loose-John Seely) – Meece break piggy bank; buy dog.
1:47 - LAF-4-1 FISHY STORY (Jack Shaindlin) – Dog does poses; dog & Jinks meet, dog hides in barrel.
3:36 - L-81 COMEDY UNDERSCORE (Spencer Moore) – Jinks “Worm’s turn to turn”; trees dog and mice.
4:33 - TC 303 ZANY COMEDY (Loose-Seely) – Tree chopped down; Jinks punches dog; Twin brother arrives.
6:03 - ZR-47 LIGHT MOVEMENT (Hormel) – Jinks chases Dixie outside; Twin punches Jinks.
6:22 - TC 303 ZANY COMEDY (Loose-Seely) – Twin punches Jinks again, Dixie points out both dogs.
6:53 - ZR-47 LIGHT MOVEMENT (Hormel) – Twin chases Jinks.
7:10 - Pixie and Dixie End Title Theme (Curtin).

Tuesday, 6 October 2009

Hedda on Huck

Long before there were catty show-biz gossips on the internet, there were catty show-biz gossips in newspapers. And two of the biggest catty show-biz gossips in print during the glittery-est era in Tinseltown were Louella Parsons and Hedda Hopper.

Louella was parodied (in a not-so-catty way) for immortality’s sake in the great Bugs Bunny cartoon ‘A Hare Grows in Manhattan’ as Lola Beverly (with Bea Benadaret doing a gushy voice instead of Lolly’s real-life nasal whine). Hedda—and I’ll stand corrected—seems to have escaped the brush of the animated satirist, perhaps because she and her hat collection became an obvious self-parody, leaving nothing to satirise.

However, Mrs. Hopper found time to put aside innuendo about Cary Grant and Randolph Scott living together and from knifing Louella in print to be swept up in one of Joe Barbera’s numerous fired-to-riches tales to promote the Hanna-Barbera studio. Evidently, Joe must have granted one mass interview to a bunch of Hollywood media or he cracked the same lines to them individually about the same time. This column is from newspapers of April 26, 1960. Two days later, Barbera’s identical “We have no time clocks” quote appeared in a rival New York Times column on the studio.

What’s nice to read is credit being given to the cartoon’s writers and voice artists. And you get an idea of the kind of potential money MGM stupidly threw away by its disdain for the concept of making cartoons for TV.


Looking at Hollywood
Speed Cartooning Puts Pair Back in Business
By HEDDA HOPPER

Bill Hanna and Joe Barbera were dropped at Metro after 20 years because a new studio head decided the “Tom & Jerry” cartoons, which they originated, made so much money on reissues they didn't need new ones. That was two and a half years ago. It looked as if the cartoon industry was washed up and Hanna and Barbera with it. But as things turned out, that kick in the pants was a major piece of luck: They got up from a prone position and developed a new streamlined method of animation. It brought theatrical cartoons, which had begun to die because of the expense of making them by hand process, back into our theaters.
“We’ve just made 12 cartoons in one month for theaters,” they told me. “Where we used to do eight a year, we now do 179 with approximately the same sized staff, due to our new streamlined technique. Even Walt Disney hasn’t been making many cartoons lately; it’s lucky for us he slowed down as we were entering the field.”
Deal Set in 15 Minutes
Not everyone can bounce up from disaster like these men. At first it looked like the end of the line. But “Tom and Jerry” had always made money and won seven Academy Awards. No human star ever got more than two or three.
“We were turned down by MCA, Ziv, and Twentieth Century-Fox, none of whom could see cartoon stories for TV. Then we went to Screen Gems, put the story board on the floor, explained it, and in 15 minutes we had a deal. We were turned down originally by Columbia also. Our first is a theatrical series, ‘Loopy De Loop,’ a charming French wolf; now we’ve signed a five-year deal. We have four half-hour shows—three on TV, another coming up this fall.”
They own their own company, and George Sidney holds stock in it. Hanna and Barbera are doing animation on two sequences of “Pepe”; one a dream sequence where Cantinflas on horseback fights windmills, while in the other he fights the bull.
“Our ‘Huckleberry Hound’ and ‘Quick Draw McGraw’ are wonderfully successful. High school and college kids go for ‘Huck’ and ‘Yogi Bear.’ Ohio State adopted them for their homecoming theme. Yale Alumni magazine named Huck as one of their favorite shows, and at the University of Washington, a fraternity changed its dinner hour so they could see Huck.”
Artists Catch On Fast.
The entire Metro cartoon staff came to work for them. People who’d operated by the old slow method for 20 years switched to the quick way like a bunch of kids. “Our story men. Warren Foster and Mike Maltese, are all of 50, and they’re fabulous. No one ages in our business and these men have been in cartooning since they were kids. Mike came to us from Warners, and has a delicious sense of humor. He used to do eight theatrical cartoons a year, but wrote 78 stories for us in nine months—the entire McGraw series. Two of our voice men—Don Messick and Daws Butler—are remarkable. They move from one voice to another, each do eight or nine voices, sometimes as many as seven in one cartoon. Butler does Huck, Yogi, Jinx [sic], Dixie, McGraw, Snooper, Oggie Doggie [sic] and Doggie Daddy and Babalu. [sic] And remember, we do four cartoons at one sitting.”
"We have no time clocks, no closed doors, no memos. The cartoons are all in color—Kellogg is spending an estimated $12 million on shows and time. And they’re made in Japanese, Spanish, French, go all over Latin America, England, New Zealand, and Australia. We’re hot in the merchandise field, too. Our Yogi Bears and Huck Hounds sell from $2.50 to $10 each, and Whitman Publishing company has some 30 books and games on our cartoons.”
(Released by the Chicago Tribune-New York News Syndicate, Inc., 1960)

Saturday, 3 October 2009

Augie Doggie — Pop's Nature Pup

Produced and Directed by Bill Hanna and Joe Barbera.
Credits: Animation – Don Williams; Layout – Walter Clinton; Backgrounds – Dick Thomas; Story – Mike Maltese; Story Director – Alex Lovy; Titles – Art Goble; Production Supervision – Howard Hanson.
Cast: Doggie Daddy – Doug Young; Augie, Josh the Owl, Duck, Skunk, Guest Cartoon Star – Daws Butler.
Released: Dec. 8 (Los Angeles), 12 (Chicago), 1959.
Episode M-012, Production J-36
Plot: Doggie Daddy decides to take a hand in Augie’s nature education.

Hanna-Barbera cartoon characters hung out with each other, but not in each other’s cartoons very much. I’m not talking about the unfunny, only-for-the-money efforts of the 1970s where they were supporting characters as Yogi taught politically-correct, network-mandated lessons to disinterested kids. I’m talking about the early cartoons, where all the main characters seen during the half hour would gather in little skits between the cartoons.

You saw them together then, and later in some cereal commercials. Occasionally, there’d be a reference to one of them in another cartoon, like Snagglepuss remarking “As Quick Draw McGraw would say ‘Oooh! That smarts!’” (with the Quick Draw theme playing in the background). But I’ve only found one where a character appears in a guest cameo in another cartoon. And that’s at the end of Pop’s Nature Pup.

This cartoon is idiosyncratic in other ways. It has a different look. It was animated by Don Williams, who spent time at Walter Lantz until 1933 when he was hired by Leon Schlesinger. He ended up at MGM in the early ‘40s, returned to Lantz for a bit, then back to Warners in the Art Davis unit. He appeared at Hanna-Barbera in 1959 before finally settling in at DePatie-Freleng.

Whether it was this way on Mike Maltese’s storyboard, I don’t know, but Williams has drawn more close-up head shots here than you’ll find in any other Augie cartoon. And what heads! The eyes are small and sometimes squint instead of blink. The angles of the heads are different, too. Some of the snouts point at 90 degrees and Augie looks up at Daddy at about a 45 degree angle, which is higher than normal.

You can see the difference right at the start when Doggie Daddy hears Augie talking to the owl. Daddy’s ear goes up and crooks itself to emphasize that he’s listening. Unfortunately, the ear vanishes for a couple of frames. Williams does this several times in the cartoon and I don’t remember that pose used anywhere else.


There are several cartoons based around Augie’s ability to communicate with things that adults can’t—animals and aliens, for example—and we find Augie chatting with a big-eyed owl.


Daddy comes into the room and after a deliberately lame joke about an owl not giving a hoot, Daddy asks why Augie’s not doing his nature study homework. Augie gets to imitate Sylvester Jr. once again by rolling up his hand, putting it to his forehead and crying “Oh, the utter shame of it!” Augie explains he doesn’t have to study because the birds and bees tell him anything he wants to know.

In this, and a couple of other scenes, it looks like Williams did all of the animation of the two characters together first, then went back and did the single character animation. You can see how the head shot of Doggie Daddy cuts to the two of them (while he’s still speaking; the two frames below are consecutive), but his ear is back in the same spot it was in before the cut to the solo shot. This happens a couple of times in the cartoon.



Dear old dad decides Augie’s conversation with an owl means he’s “cracking up” and decides to take his son back to nature to help him with his homework. Williams does something different here. Instead of Doggie Daddy’s car rolling along past the same trees ten times, he has the car shaking in a two-drawing cycle, with the characters and contents in the car shaking with it. It’s slowed down a bit here.


A duck flies overhead but when Daddy remarks it’s flying south for the winter, Augie calls to it. The duck lands on the car and Augie explains he was telling the duck it was flying the wrong way. We don’t even see the duck leave. Williams saves animation by just having a close-up of Augie’s head turning.

Next is a bit that seems like out of a Foghorn Leghorn cartoon. And it is. It was adapted in Crockett-Doodle-Do (1960). Daddy shows Augie how to make a fire but fails. Augie decides to show Daddy how to do it and Daddy catches on fire. The limited animation really hurts here. All we get is a smoke cloud and a not-too-exaggerated singed head. I still don’t understand how Augie warns Daddy he’s too close, but Augie is closer to the fire (which we don’t see) and doesn’t get burned.

Daddy’s next lesson is to go look for water, but Augie takes care of that by doing an Indian rain dance and bringing a cloud (which he thanks) which showers into a pot.


A “bee’s nest” in a tree has honey, and Daddy decides to help himself. The bees don’t like it and (in the shape of an arrow) chase Daddy into a log. Augie doesn’t panic. He just buzzes to the bees to stop, and they give their opinion of his father in a sight gag. “My dad don’t know from bees,” is Augie’s pun (Augie should work on his grammar instead of nature studies).


A turnip-baited trap is rigged up by Daddy to catch “a ferocious wild animal.” Daddy snares a skunk but thinks it’s “black and white pussy cat with a big bushy tail” until the expected happens. We don’t see Daddy get sprayed; instead, we get a reaction shot of Augie with the spraying hinted at by a drum roll and a cymbal on the sound track. Augie talks in skunk to the critter.


Daddy exclaims he can’t get in the car smelling like a skunk. Augie knows someone who can drive them home. “But Augie, boy, bears aren’t smart enough to drive.” Ah, but this bear is. And it turns out to be our old pal Yogi Bear, making a unique cameo appearance, who lets out with his “smarter” catch-phrase. Daddy winds up the cartoon, happily admitting Augie is “smarter than the average son,” which is evident in future “scientific” cartoons where Augie’s doing stuff with test tubes.


Several Phil Green music pieces bring to mind Augie cartoons when you hear them, and we get a couple of personal favourites here. Let me see if I can try to explain this.

13 or so years ago, Rhino Records put out a CD of early Hanna-Barbera music, including nine Phil Green underscores from Capitol Hi-Q that were originally in the EMI Photoplay library. Two cues were said to be part of the ‘Big City Suite,’ which is an EMI name. Both are in this cartoon. However, I have cue sheets for two different Big City Suites and one of the two is not among them. So either it’s from a third Big City Suite or it’s from something else. However, I do have the Capitol name for that cue, so what you’ll see below is a ? followed by a Capitol name. GR 248 is the main underscore from Big City Suite No 2.


0:00 – AUGIE MAIN TITLE THEME (Hanna-Barbera-Curtin).
0:24 – EM-107D LIGHT MOVEMENT (Green) – Augie talks to owl; Daddy decides to help.
2:00 – GR 154 PICNIC OR COUNTRY SCENE (Green) – Augie talks to duck; fire-starting gag; Daddy hands Augie pot.
3:58 – Indian dance music (Jack Shaindlin?) – Cloud rains in pot.
4:23 – CB-89A ROMANTIC JAUNT (Emil Cadkin-Harry Bluestone) – Daddy goes for honey in tree.
4:45 – fast circus chase music (Shaindlin?) – Bees chase Daddy into log.
5:15 – GR 65 BUSH BABY (Green) – Daddy in pond; Daddy sets trap.
6:09 – GR 248 STREETS OF THE CITY (Green) – Skunk in trap.
6:45 – Vaudeville up-scale music (Shaindlin) – Daddy driven home in cart.
7:09 – AUGIE END TITLE THEME (Hanna-Barbera-Curtin).

Monday, 28 September 2009

Top Cat! Starring the Voice of ... Who?

A note from Yowp: Today is Arnold Stang’s birthday, so this post is in honour of the occasion. Your friendly Yowp wishes him many more filled with good health.

Some voice actors are so right for the characters they play, you wonder how anyone else could possibly have been considered for the roles. You can picture Joe Barbera in 1960, looking over ideas for The Flintstones, simply picking up the phone, calling Alan Reed and telling him “You’re perfect for Fred. Come over and voice him. See you at 1:30.”

It’s not that simple, of course. There are auditions. And in the case of The Flintstones, it’s surprising to think that Alan Reed and Mel Blanc were not the first choices for Fred and Barney, and they re-did dialogue tracks that had been recorded by Bill Thompson and Hal Smith in the roles.

Barbera had the same problem with another cartoon. And, again, it’s difficult to picture anybody but Arnold Stang playing the Sgt. Bilko-esque character. But Stang wasn’t the first choice. He wasn’t even the second choice. The actor originally hired was someone you likely have never heard of. That’s because he never, before or since, provided a voice for an animated character. A syndicated column by Robert E. Stansfield dated May 28, 1961, fills us in.


Michael O’Shea had been slated as the voice of the new fall entry, “Top Cat,” a “family entertainment” cartoon feature slated for prime evening time this fall. However, he is out because of other commitments and is being replaced by the voice of Arnold Stang. Stang is already the voice of “Herman, the Brave Mouse” on a current cartoon show. Another cat lined up for fall is Maurice Gossfield [sic], the Doberman on Phil Silver’s [sic] Army comedy series; and Allen Jenkins is the voice of a police officer (a cartoon human). Three cartoon cats are still hunting voices.

Stansfield (or his source) was pulling a few punches. Another article of the same time quotes Hanna-Barbera Productions as saying O’Shea was up for a live-action role. But Alan Dinehart, who started with Hanna-Barbera on The Flintstones, and whose credits include the immortal and highly-respected Super President and a much-beloved animated version of Mr. T., soon gave a different published version of why the man who played the puss got the boot. This is from a syndicated column of Saturday, September 23, 1961:

Viewing TV With Hal Humphrey
Cartoon Shows On TV Bread and Butter To Many

Hollywood—“I like this job because I don't have to deal with the stars—if he gets tough I just erase him,” says Alan Dinehart, who has the unique job of directing “The Flintstones” cartoon series (Fridays, ABC).
Dinehart is joking, of course. Actually his work is doubled because he is working with two stars. There is the one the artist puts on paper and the flesh-and-blood character who furnishes the voice.
After sitting in with the writers and artists, Dinehart moves into the recording studio where the voice actors are matched with the animated action.
He has had his troubles finding the right voice for the title role in the new cartoon series, "Top Cat," which goes on ABC (Channel 13) Wednesday at 8:30 p.m.
Actor Michael O'Shea was first for the job but didn’t read fast enough, according to Dinehart.
Took Too Long
“Instead of the normal three hours to do a half-hour episode, it was taking O’Shea six hours, so we had to drop him,” Dinehart explains.
Daws Butler, who does most of the voices for “Huckleberry Hound” and “Yogi Bear” (two other Hanna-Barbera productions), was called in. He could not hit on a voice which had enough of its own character to suit Dinehart.
Now Arnold Stang, one-time stooge for Milton Berle, is Top Cat. Maurice Gosfield, who did Doberman on Phil Silvers’ “Bilko” show, is the voice for Benny the Ball in “Top Cat.” Allen Jenkins’ voice will give life to one of the cats.
These are pretty big names, and you might ask how come they are willing to bury their identity behind a cartoon character? The answer is brutal, but simple. Nobody was knocking down their door with offers to do anything else.
Dinehart, himself, says this is why he is directing cartoon characters instead of live people. He started out in the footsteps of his father, the late Alan Dinehart, Sr. After a short whirl at acting on the Broadway stage and a five-year stint in World War II, young Alan (he’s 44 now) became one of TV’s pioneer directing talents.
His most fruitful job was directing the Alan Young comedy series on CBS in the early ’50s. It gave him a reputation for being an exceptional comedy director, but when comics began dropping off TV like autumn leaves, Alan Dinehart dropped, too.
“I ‘got religion’ and went with an advertising agency and met some great fellows,” Alan recalls. “I remember one who had three vents in his suitcoat—I mean on each side!”
Had Enough
Dinehart left that rarefied atmosphere of Madison Avenue when he was asked to supervise the “Arthur Murray Dance Party.” That was carrying comedy too far.
Joe Barbera called him in New York and offered him a job with the thriving Hanna-Barbera cartoon factory.
“I confess I wasn’t thrilled but when Joe said ‘The Flintstones’ was about Stone Age and then offered to pay my expenses to Hollywood, I was hooked.”
Although a huge commercial success (big ratings) its first season, “The Flintstones” was considerably less than an artistic smash. Dinehart says it is much improved this season, and he hopes the humor will be a bit more adult.
As might be expected, the Hanna-Barbera success with “The Flintstones” not only is giving birth to “Top Cat,” but other cartooneries are coming up this fall with “Bullwinkle,” “Alvin and the Chipmunks” and “Calvin and the Colonel” (with Freeman Gosden and Charles Correll of Amos ‘n’ Andy).

It’s understandable Daws would have been pulled from the role. He was already doing a Phil Silvers-type voice for Hokey Wolf.

Dinehart may not have had much choice but to reveal why O’Shea found himself fired. Arnold Stang himself talked about it in a syndicated column interview by Jack Gaver, dated June 16, 1961, though Stang shows his class by not naming names:


“They tried a couple of other voices for T.C. — in fact, one actor finished five episodes — but they decided they didn’t reflect the character of T.C. properly, and I was asked to take a shot at it. So, we started all over from scratch.”

Colourful characters seem to have hung around the world of animation back then, and O’Shea was no exception. Let’s check our newspaper clippings about Edward Francis Michael Patrick Joseph O’Shea:

• March 19, 1947: O’Shea’s wife filed for divorce, citing desertion. He married Virginia Mayo on July 8. In 1951, his ex sued him for $25,730. He tried to get a reduction in alimony the following year.

• June 10, 1953: “Michael O’Shea will be able to vary the monotony of his appearances in court (alimony troubles) by appearing in a movie for a change.”

• August 24, 1959: “BRISTOL, Pa. (AP) – Actor Michael O’Shea was arrested Monday after allegedly displaying a pistol in defense of his actress wife, Virginia Mayo, during an argument over the air conditioning in a restaurant here.”

O’Shea died of a heart attack in his New York apartment on December 5, 1973.

Getting back to Top Cat’s voice, what’s surprising is there’s no mention in any of these stories of a talented mimic and former radio actor who could do a pretty funny Silvers-like voice. In fact, Joe Barbera used that very actor and voice in the 1960-61 season of The Flintstones. The voice belonged to Jerry Mann, who played a variety of characters in several episodes that year, but is mostly forgotten because the show’s original end credits were replaced when it went into syndication decades ago. Cartoon producer/writer Mark Evanier speculated in a Usenet conversation in 2000 it was “conjecture” that Mann auditioned for the role. If so, Mann was evidently not acceptable or available—he didn’t die until December 1987—or perhaps ran into outside politics as Lucille Bliss did twice when she landed title roles in Ruff and Reddy and The Jetsons. But that’s a story for another time. And we’ll tell you a little more about the always enjoyable Arnold Stang as the most effectual T.C., too.

Happy Birthday, I Theen’

My favourite H-B show debuted on North American TV on this day (the internet notwithstanding, I can find no contemporary record it aired any earlier).

So, a happy 50th birthday to the The Quick Draw McGraw show and Quick Draw McGraw, Baba Looey, Snooper, Blabber Mouse, Augie Doggie and Doggie Daddy.

And a thanks to everyone who had a part in creating it. Especially Doug Young, the voice of Doggie Daddy, who is enjoying life apparently down the I-5 from me in Seattle (he’s the tall one in the poor quality picture above, with Don Messick and Daws Butler).